Washington Hockey Insider has no direct affiliation to the Washington Capitals, NHL or NHLPA
Trade options the Capitals could explore to stay afloat without Pierre-Luc Dubois
Photo credit: James Guillory-Imagn Images
With Pierre-Luc Dubois sidelined for up to four months following abdominal surgery, the Washington Capitals suddenly find themselves at a crossroads. Sitting near the bottom of the Metropolitan Division and fighting through a five-game losing streak, the team faces a familiar question: ride it out with youth or make a move to stabilize the lineup?
General manager Chris Patrick has preached patience, but the injury to Dubois - coupled with continued scoring struggles - could nudge Washington toward the trade market. The team doesn't need a blockbuster, but it does need depth and reliability down the middle.
Depth and balance more important than big names
Thompson is a prime example of elite upside. He's got strong trade-value rankings and could move if his current club falters. For Washington, landing a weapon like that would instantly boost 1A scoring. The catch? His contract and the return required will be heavy. The Caps would need to give up both cap flexibility and quality assets. If they believe their window is now, pushing hard for Thompson makes sense. If not, the cost may outweigh the reward.
2) Jared McCann
McCann offers a more attainable upgrade. He's a consistent 20-goal scorer with years of term and a cap hit that fits better than a big star. Reports indicate his current club might be willing to deal him to reset. If Washington opts for incremental improvement rather than blockbuster, McCann could slot into their middle six or second line and fill a scoring hole without mortgaging the future. The risk: he's not a game changer.
3) Ryan O'Reilly
O'Reilly brings veteran savvy, face‐off strength and playoff experience. But the upside is lower, and his age and contract term reduce flexibility. For Washington, he could stabilize a third line or shore up depth, but he won't be the focal point of the offense. If their primary need is leadership and defensive zone strength rather than scoring boost, O'Reilly fits. For scoring punch, the other two are more attractive.
Which path should Washington choose?
If the Capitals believe they are a serious threat this spring, going all-in on someone like Thompson makes sense but comes with risk. Opting for McCann gives smart upside without full risk. Choosing O'Reilly sends a message of reinforcing depth and reliability, but it won't move the needle offensively in a major way.
Washington's challenge is balancing «make the trade now» with «maintain roster flexibility and future assets.» Whoever they target, the alignment with their window, cap strategy and vision will matter more than simply «get a player.»
| POLL | ||
NOVEMBRE 9 | 35 ANSWERS Trade options the Capitals could explore to stay afloat without Pierre-Luc Dubois Should the Capitals make a trade? | ||
| yes | 30 | 85.7 % |
| no | 5 | 14.3 % |
| List of polls | ||